The Federal Trade Commission waded into the question of ethics in the
blogosphere last year, when it issued guidelines requiring bloggers to
disclose if a company pays them or supplies them with products.
“In
some ways, bloggers want to be treated like traditional media, but they
are not held to the same journalistic standards,” says Bailey. “They
don’t fact check, necessarily, or get both sides of the story. There’s
no governing standards or benchmarks for bloggers.”
That is
one reason Bailey encourages companies that want to get their messages
out to mom bloggers to do their homework and get to know bloggers
before making a pitch.
“A lot of times, companies will just
Google ‘top mommy bloggers’ or look at the Nielson list without going
to their site and reading what they are about,” says Bailey. “Not every
blogger is the right fit. Disney wouldn’t want to associate with a
blogger who uses the F-bomb.”
For their part, mom bloggers
in Orange County have their own horror stories about what some public
relations folks have asked of them. Massura has her own ethics policy
posted in her blog, starting with the statement “I never make stuff up.”
“The
ethics policy is mostly responses to real-life situations. I was asked
to make up a post about something after the fact, like they would give
me $50 if you say you went to this play and it was good,” Massura says.
“Some PR folks misunderstand and do not quite realize that bloggers
have ethics. We want to live up to our readers.”
Massura
says that, while she does review products, she does not do negative
reviews. If something wouldn’t have a positive review, she won’t post
it. She also keeps at least a 20-to-1 ratio of regular posts versus
product reviews (“what I call, ‘pimpin’ posts’”), because, she says,
“You don’t want to be the ginsu knife salesman.”
Another
popular Orange County mom blogger, Suzanne Broughton (pictured above), says that, while
she accepts free tickets for things to review, such as Disney on Ice
shows or the Discovery Science Center, she steers clears of any product
placement.